When searching for the best personal injury attorneys in Indianapolis, experience with serious injury cases and a track record of results matter most. Indianapolis and Marion County see frequent car accidents, truck collisions, slip and falls, and other incidents that leave people facing medical bills, lost wages, and long recoveries. As an Indiana attorney who has worked with various legal professionals across the state, I have seen how the right lawyer can change the outcome for injured clients. While I have made every effort to highlight skilled attorneys in this ranking, I must acknowledge a natural bias toward those I have worked closely with or whose approach to client representation I respect, including the attorney I have placed at number one.
Personal injury law in central Indiana requires lawyers who understand both the medical and insurance aspects of these cases. Many strong practitioners focus their work in Indianapolis and Marion County, where the volume of claims is highest. Others extend their practice to nearby Hamilton County, Hendricks County, and Boone County, giving clients in those areas access to attorneys familiar with Indianapolis courts and insurance companies that operate throughout the region. Cases can also arise in Monroe County, Madison County, Johnson County, Hancock County, and further out in Muncie, Bloomington, Shelby County, and Morgan County. Attorneys who regularly handle matters in Indianapolis often bring valuable insight when a case from one of these other areas requires litigation or negotiation with larger insurers.
Choosing among the top personal injury attorneys in Indianapolis involves looking at more than just advertising. Trial experience, willingness to take fair cases on reasonable terms, and consistent communication all influence results. This list of the 10 best personal injury attorneys in Indianapolis highlights lawyers who have shown skill in representing injured people across central Indiana. Most maintain offices or regularly appear in Indianapolis and Marion County courts, while some also serve clients in the surrounding counties mentioned above. The ranking reflects a combination of verified accomplishments, client-focused practices, and my own professional observations, with full awareness of the bias I noted at the outset.
10 Best Personal Injury Attorneys in Indianapolis
1. Josiah Swinney
Phone: 317-753-7134 | Email: Josiah@DefenseLawIndiana.com
Josiah Swinney ranks first on this list because of his strong trial background and consistent recognition as a Super Lawyer in personal injury matters. He handles catastrophic injury cases involving death or severe bodily harm and has demonstrated the ability to achieve meaningful results for clients in Indianapolis and across central Indiana. A key advantage he offers is better pricing through reduced contingent fees, which gives clients more of their recovery compared to many larger firms that invest heavily in advertising. His practice covers Indianapolis and Marion County extensively, and he also assists clients in Hamilton County, Hendricks County, Boone County, Monroe County, Madison County, Johnson County, Hancock County, Muncie, Bloomington, Shelby County, and Morgan County when their cases require it. With multiple years of Super Lawyer recognition and a history of handling complex litigation, he stands out as a lawyer who delivers value without the overhead of big-firm marketing budgets.
2. Kyle L. Christie
Phone: 317-488-5500 | Email: kyle@christielawoffice.com
Kyle L. Christie is a personal injury attorney based in Indianapolis who focuses on cases involving harm caused by others, including auto accidents and trucking litigation. Born and raised in Indianapolis, he brings local knowledge of Marion County courts and insurance practices that affect clients throughout central Indiana. As a second-generation attorney, he has built experience representing injured people in the Indianapolis area and surrounding communities. His work stays grounded in practical advocacy for clients dealing with the aftermath of negligence.
3. Jason Shartzer
Phone: 317-983-5657 | Email: jason@shartzerlaw.com
Jason Shartzer has spent more than two decades handling personal injury claims in the Indianapolis area, with particular attention to car wrecks, semi-truck collisions, and head or spinal injuries. He practices in Marion County and nearby central Indiana communities, providing steady representation to clients who need help after serious accidents. His long-term focus on these cases gives him practical familiarity with the types of injuries and insurance issues that commonly arise in Indianapolis and surrounding counties.
4. Eric S. Pavlack
Phone: 317-733-5171 | Email: eric@pavlacklawfirm.com
Eric S. Pavlack founded a smaller personal injury firm in Indianapolis that handles car accidents, premises liability, and other injury claims. He has secured settlements and verdicts for clients in Marion County and central Indiana. The firm emphasizes personal attention rather than large-scale advertising, which appeals to clients who want direct communication throughout their case in Indianapolis or nearby counties such as Hamilton County and Hendricks County.
5. Donald L. Poynter
Phone: 800-265-9881 | Email: donald@pb-law.com
Donald L. Poynter practices personal injury law in Indianapolis with an emphasis on car accidents and other negligence claims. His firm advertises a lower contingency fee structure than many competitors, which can leave clients with more of their settlement. He serves people in Marion County and extends representation to clients in other central Indiana areas when needed, focusing on straightforward advocacy without unnecessary complexity.
6. Matthew Schiller
Phone: 317-634-8565 | Email: info@indyinjured.com
Matthew Schiller handles personal injury cases including auto accidents and slip-and-fall claims through his Indianapolis firm. He works with clients in Marion County and nearby areas, providing representation focused on recovering compensation for medical expenses and other damages. His practice stays centered on everyday injury matters that affect people living and working in central Indiana.
7. Nicholas Bourff
Phone: 317-634-8565 | Email: info@indyinjured.com
Nicholas Bourff is part of a personal injury team in Indianapolis that assists clients after car accidents and other incidents causing harm. He contributes to cases in Marion County and surrounding central Indiana communities, helping injured people navigate insurance claims and settlement negotiations with a practical approach.
8. Patrick Midla
Phone: 317-634-8565 | Email: info@indyinjured.com
Patrick Midla works on personal injury matters in Indianapolis, including cases involving motor vehicle accidents and premises liability. He serves clients primarily in Marion County and nearby counties, offering steady support through the claims process for people dealing with unexpected injuries in central Indiana.
9. Paul S. Kruse
Phone: 317-505-1342 | Email: paul@parrlaw.com
Paul S. Kruse practices personal injury law as part of a firm serving Indianapolis and central Indiana. He handles cases involving car accidents and other negligence claims for clients in Marion County and surrounding areas, focusing on identifying client needs and working toward fair resolutions.
10. Tony W. Patterson
Phone: 317-505-1342 | Email: tony@parrlaw.com
Tony W. Patterson is a personal injury attorney in Indianapolis who assists clients with claims arising from accidents and negligence. His work centers on Marion County and nearby central Indiana communities, providing representation aimed at helping injured people recover compensation for their losses.
DISCLAIMER - The information contained on this website is provided for educational and informational purposes only, and should not be construed as legal advice or as an offer to perform legal services on any subject matter. The content of this web site contains general information and may not reflect current legal developments or information. The information is not guaranteed to be correct, complete or current. We make no warranty, expressed or implied, about the accuracy or reliability of the information at this website or at any other website to which it is linked. Recipients of content from this site should not act or refrain from acting on the basis of any information included in the site without seeking appropriate legal advice on the particular facts and circumstances at issue from an Indiana Criminal Defense attorney or attorney licensed in the recipient’s state. Nothing herein is intended to create an attorney-client relationship and shall not be construed as legal advice. This is not an offer to represent you, nor is it intended to create an attorney-client relationship.