As an Indiana criminal defense attorney, I take a client centered approach to each case.  I treat each client the way I would want to be treated if I were in their shoes, interacting with and representing them directly. I realize that every one of my client’s is a unique person with specific goals, and not merely a file.  As an Indiana criminal lawyer, I believe it is my job to help you get through a case as painlessly as possible – without passing judgment.  I am aware that as humans, even the best of us occasionally make mistakes.  I believe that anyone in our legal system who is accused of wrongdoing deserves to have a criminal defense attorney fighting for their best interests in court and protecting their Constitutional rights.

For additional information, please click on any of the following links:

The Courts and Criminal Justice System in Lagrange, Lagrange County, Indiana

LaGrange, the county seat of LaGrange County, Indiana, is a small, tight-knit community of about 2,700 residents, nestled in the heart of Northern Indiana’s Amish country. Known for its rolling farmlands, vibrant Amish culture, and annual events like the LaGrange County 4-H Fair, LaGrange embodies a rural charm that sets it apart from Indiana’s more urban counties. The county, with a population of roughly 40,000, is characterized by its agricultural economy, small-town values, and a significant Amish population that influences local customs and legal considerations. The criminal justice system in LaGrange County is a cohesive network comprising the courts, prosecutor’s office, jail, probation office, and community corrections, each tailored to serve the unique needs of this rural community. Operating in a region where traditional values meet modern challenges like substance abuse and economic pressures, the system reflects LaGrange County’s distinct identity. Below, we explore each component of the criminal justice system, highlighting their specific functions in LaGrange and LaGrange County, while incorporating details that capture the area’s unique character.

The LaGrange County Circuit Court and Superior Court form the backbone of the judicial system, handling criminal cases ranging from minor misdemeanors to serious felonies. The Circuit Court, located at 105 North Detroit Street in the historic courthouse in downtown LaGrange, is presided over by an elected judge who brings a local perspective to the bench. This court manages a variety of cases, including felonies like drug trafficking or theft, which are significant in LaGrange County due to its proximity to major highways like the Indiana Toll Road, which can facilitate drug-related activities. The Superior Court, also based in LaGrange, focuses on misdemeanors, traffic violations, and juvenile matters, often addressing issues like underage drinking or petty theft that reflect the county’s rural and youthful demographic. LaGrange County’s courts are notable for their consideration of the Amish community, where judges may adapt proceedings to accommodate cultural practices, such as allowing alternative forms of identification for Amish defendants who avoid government-issued IDs. The courthouse, a centerpiece of LaGrange’s quaint downtown with its local shops and horse-drawn buggies, serves as a community hub where justice is administered with an awareness of local traditions. Individuals navigating these courts often seek guidance from a defense attorney to understand the nuances of local judicial processes.

The LaGrange County Prosecutor’s Office, housed within the courthouse complex, is responsible for representing the state in criminal prosecutions. Led by an elected prosecuting attorney, the office determines which cases to pursue, what charges to file, and whether to offer plea agreements. In LaGrange County, the prosecutor’s office prioritizes addressing crimes that impact the rural community, such as property crimes tied to agricultural theft or drug offenses linked to methamphetamine use, a growing concern in rural Northern Indiana. The office works closely with local law enforcement, including the LaGrange County Sheriff’s Department and the LaGrange Police Department, to build cases that reflect the community’s values, such as preserving public safety in a county where trust and neighborliness are paramount. The prosecutor’s office also engages with community stakeholders, including Amish leaders, to ensure culturally sensitive approaches to prosecution, particularly in cases involving Amish youth or families. Those facing charges may consult a criminal attorney to navigate the prosecutor’s strategies and advocate for their rights within this community-focused system.

The LaGrange County Jail, located at 0875 South State Road 9 just outside LaGrange, serves as the primary detention facility for individuals awaiting trial or serving short sentences. With a capacity to house around 140 inmates, the jail is relatively small, reflecting the county’s low crime rate compared to urban areas. However, it often manages a steady flow of inmates due to drug-related arrests and DUIs, which are notable challenges in a county with limited public transportation and a reliance on rural roadways. The jail offers programs like substance abuse education and religious services, tailored to the county’s faith-based community, including Amish and Mennonite inmates who may request specific accommodations. The facility’s staff, many of whom are local residents, bring a community-oriented approach to their work, balancing security with an understanding of the social dynamics in LaGrange County, where many inmates are known to the community. For those detained, working with a criminal lawyer can be essential in navigating pre-trial processes, such as bail hearings, which are influenced by the county’s limited resources and tight-knit community dynamics.

The LaGrange County Probation Department, based near the courthouse in LaGrange, oversees individuals sentenced to probation as an alternative to incarceration. In a rural county like LaGrange, probation is a critical tool for reducing jail overcrowding and promoting rehabilitation, particularly for non-violent offenders involved in drug or alcohol-related offenses. Probation officers work closely with local organizations, such as the Bowen Center for mental health and addiction services, to develop supervision plans that address underlying issues like substance abuse or economic hardship. For example, probationers may be required to participate in community service at local events like the Shipshewana Mayfest, reinforcing ties to the community while fulfilling court obligations. The department’s approach is shaped by LaGrange County’s rural character, with officers often traveling to remote areas to meet with clients, including Amish individuals who may rely on horse-and-buggy transportation. The probation office also supports the county’s Problem-Solving Court, a drug court program that integrates treatment with judicial oversight, reflecting LaGrange’s commitment to addressing addiction as a root cause of crime. Those on probation may engage a criminal defense attorney to address compliance issues or modifications to their probation terms, ensuring adherence to court expectations.

LaGrange County Community Corrections, located in LaGrange, provides alternatives to traditional incarceration, offering programs like home detention, work release, and day reporting. In a county where agriculture and small businesses, such as Shipshewana’s Amish markets, drive the economy, community corrections programs are designed to allow offenders to maintain employment while serving their sentences, a critical factor in a region where job loss can lead to further legal issues. For instance, participants in the work release program might continue working at local farms or businesses like Yoder’s Meat and Cheese Company, contributing to the economy while meeting court requirements. The program incorporates drug testing and counseling, addressing the county’s substance abuse challenges, which are amplified by its rural isolation and access to highways. LaGrange County’s Community Corrections is notable for its flexibility, accommodating the needs of Amish participants who may require alternative monitoring methods due to their avoidance of modern technology. The program’s collaboration with local churches and nonprofits reflects the county’s faith-based community, ensuring a holistic approach to rehabilitation. Individuals in these programs often work with a criminal defense lawyer to navigate program requirements and ensure their rights are protected.

LaGrange County’s criminal justice system operates within a broader context shaped by the county’s unique characteristics. The area’s significant Amish population, one of the largest in the United States, influences every aspect of the system, from court proceedings to community corrections, requiring cultural sensitivity and adaptability. The county’s agricultural economy, centered on dairy farming and small-scale manufacturing, creates both opportunities and challenges, as economic pressures can contribute to property crimes or substance abuse. LaGrange’s small-town charm, evident in its historic downtown and community events like the Topeka Fall Festival, reflects a community that values tradition and mutual support. The criminal justice system is deeply embedded in this context, with courts and probation programs partnering with local organizations, such as the LaGrange County Community Foundation, to provide support services like job training or addiction recovery. The county’s rural setting, with its sprawling farmlands and limited infrastructure, also shapes the system, requiring innovative solutions like mobile probation services to reach remote residents.

The criminal justice system in LaGrange faces challenges unique to a rural, Amish-influenced county. Limited funding means that facilities like the jail and probation office must operate efficiently, often relying on community partnerships to provide services. The opioid epidemic, a growing issue in rural Indiana, has prompted the courts and prosecutor’s office to adopt progressive measures, such as the drug court and diversion programs, aimed at rehabilitation rather than punishment. These initiatives are tailored to LaGrange County’s needs, recognizing that many offenders are local residents who will remain part of the community, whether in the Amish or “English” populations. The system’s emphasis on community-based solutions, from probation to community corrections, reflects LaGrange’s commitment to maintaining its close-knit character, where rehabilitation and reintegration are prioritized.

Navigating the criminal justice system in LaGrange County requires an understanding of its localized and culturally sensitive approach. The courts, prosecutor’s office, jail, probation office, and community corrections each play a distinct role, but their interconnectedness reflects LaGrange’s small-town ethos and Amish heritage. For those facing charges, a defense attorney familiar with the local system can provide valuable insight into the nuances of LaGrange County’s judicial processes, including its accommodations for Amish defendants. Similarly, a criminal attorney can offer guidance through complex plea negotiations or probation requirements, ensuring individuals are well-represented in a system that balances accountability with rehabilitation. The criminal justice system in LaGrange is not just a set of institutions but a reflection of the county’s values, challenges, and commitment to fostering a safe and inclusive community.

Call 317-695-7700 for a Free Consultation with a Criminal Defense Attorney about Your Case in Lagrange, Lagrange County, Indiana

Call 317-695-7700 for a free consultation with an Indiana defense attorney if you have questions about a criminal matter in Lagrange, Lagrange County, Indiana.  I have practiced criminal defense my entire career, have taught criminal law at the IU School of Law, and have personally handled thousands of cases. I provide reasonably priced criminal defense representation (compared to other top criminal attorneys in the State) and practice in the entire State of Indiana. I look forward to hearing from you.

Misdemeanor Criminal Defense Attorney for Lagrange, Lagrange County, Indiana

There are 3 levels of misdemeanor cases in Indiana which are A misdemeanor, B misdemeanor, and C misdemeanor. A misdemeanor is the most serious while C misdemeanor is the least serious. A misdemeanor cases carry a minimum sentence of zero days and a maximum sentence of 365 days. B misdemeanor cases carry a minimum sentence of zero days and a maximum sentence of 180 days. C misdemeanor cases carry a minimum sentence of zero days and a maximum sentence of 60 days. Misdemeanor cases carry lesser penalties than felony cases, but the conviction itself can still make it more difficult to obtain employment, so it is important not to brush off a misdemeanor criminal charge.

Level 6 Felony Criminal Defense Attorney for Lagrange, Lagrange County, Indiana

A level 6 felony carries a potential penalty range of ½ a year to 2.5 years with 1 year being the presumptive sentence. While a level 6 felony is a low level felony, being a convicted felon can carry serious penalties beyond the sentence, including the loss of legal rights such as the right to possess a firearm. Being a convicted felon can also ake it more difficult to obtain employment. Some (but not all) level 6 felony cases are eligible for alternate misdemeanor sentencing, which is often called AMS for short. AMS allows what would otherwise be a low level felony to be converted to a misdemeanor. AMS is most often addressed at the time of sentencing. However, if AMS is not brought up at the time of sentencing, AMS can still be requested at a later point in time. AMS generally can be ordered (1) at the front – meaning that on the day of sentencing, the conviction will go on the defendant’s record as a misdemeanor, or (2) at the back – meaning that the conviction will begin as a felony but can change if the defendant successfully completes the sentence. It is important to remember that when AMS is ordered at the back, if there are violations of probation, it is likely that the conviction will stay a felony.

Major Felony Criminal Defense Attorney for Lagrange, Lagrange County, Indiana

Felony cases that are level 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 are considered major felony cases. Murder cases are the most serious major felony charge. A level 5 felony carries a potential penalty range of 1 year to 6 years with 3 years being the presumptive sentence. A level 4 carries a potential penalty range of 2 years to 12 years with 6 years being the presumptive sentence. A level 3 felony carries a potential penalty range of 3 years to 16 years with 9 years being the presumptive sentence. A level 2 felony carries a potential penalty range of 10 years to 30 years with 17.5 years being the presumptive sentence. A level 1 felony carries a potential penalty range of 20 years to 40 years with 30 years being the presumptive sentence. A murder case carries a potential penalty range of 45 years to 65 years with 55 years being the presumptive sentence.

Navigating the Lagrange, Lagrange County, Indiana Legal System with a Criminal Defense Attorney

If you are accused of a felony or misdemeanor in Lagrange, Lagrange County, Indiana, the process generally starts with a summons or arrest and can end with charges being dropped or a conviction through a guilty plea or trial. Without a good defense attorney, the process can be confusing and stressful and put your liberty at jeopardy.  In Indiana, misdemeanors can carry up to a year of incarceration and felonies can result in prison time for longer periods of time.  Even a short period of incarceration can cause an individual major life problems, such as loss of employment.

Convictions also have long-lasting effects, like court-mandated supervision, fines, drug treatment programs, community service, and more. Plus, the stigma of a conviction makes it more difficult to tough to find a job, get an education, access public benefits, or find housing.

When facing charges in Indiana, your first move should be to call a good and knowledgeable criminal defense attorney.

Jeff Cardella has helped thousands of clients dealing with felonies and misdemeanors in Indiana. Jeff Cardella provides solid legal representation and is committed to defending your rights.

Cases generally begin with an investigation. Someone makes a complaint with the police or an individual might be arrested at the scene.  When an on scene arrest does not occur, law enforcement might ask a judge for a warrant based on probable cause. If police think you committed a crime, they can seek a Judicial arrest warrant. If they suspect you have contraband or evidence in your place or vehicle, they can request  a search warrant, which might lead to your arrest.

If an arrest occurs, the individual is taken to the jail or will receive a summons telling them when to appear in court for the initial hearing. During processing, law enforcement will obtain fingerprints and take the defendants picture.  If incarcerated, the defendant will generally have a bond review hearing to determine how much bond must be posted in order to be released. The defendant might merely be ordered to re-appear in Court or might be supervised by Pretrial Services (which could mean drug tests, reporting in person or by phone, GPS ankle monitoring, and/or no contact orders).

At the initial hearing, charges will be read and a plea of not guilty is entered on the defendant’s behalf.

As the case progresses, there will be hearings before the Judge.  If there is a failure to appear, a warrant is likely to be issued, which can result in being incarcerated until trial.  The prosecutor might make plea or diversion offers at any status hearing. Deferred Prosecution is an agreement where the prosecutor agrees to dismiss your case if you do certain things (pay money, community service, classes, etc).  A plea offer is a deal negotiated between the prosecutor and you that might result in dismissal of some charges or a lighter sentence.

Any motions to suppress evidence based on Constitutional violations will likely be heard at these hearings.

If there is no diversion, dismissal, or plea, then the case will generally proceed to trial. 

Before trial, your defense attorney plans a defense strategy. The trial starts with opening statements from the prosecutor and your defense attorney. The prosecutor presents their case, calling witnesses and questioning them. Your attorney is allowed to cross-examine each witness.  After the state rests, the Defense Attorney will often move for Judgement on the Evidence, arguing that the case should be dismissed for lack of evidence.  The defense then has the opportunity to present evidence (although a defendant has a right to remain silent).   

After each side makes closing arguments, the Jury will decide if you are guilty or not guilty.  If convicted, the judge decides your sentence, considering things like the severity of the crime and your criminal history.

Federal Criminal Defense Attorney in Indiana

Federal cases generally carry far harsher penalties as compared with State cases. It is not rare that a charge that would result in probation in State Court could result in over a decade of prison in Federal Court. If you are being charge with a Federal case it is important to take the case very seriously as many federal cases result in significant prison time. It is also important to be mindful that Federal cases are far more time consuming for the attorney and legal representation can be very expensive. For more information about representation in Federal Court, click here.

Miscellaneous Information

For questions about specific areas of Indiana criminal law, click here.   Additional information about my office is available on the home page and the in the news page.

Frequently Asked Questions

• How much do you charge for criminal defense representation in Indiana?

For the majority of cases, I charge a flat fee.  This fee varies from case to case and can be affected by many factors, such as the level of the charges, the likelihood of a trial or litigation, the amount of trial preparation that is anticipated, and the actual county.  I am of the opinion that my fees are very reasonable, compared to other top criminal attorneys in the State of Indiana.  However, for people who are looking for bargain basement pricing or low end discount legal services, there might be better options.  There are many alternative lawyers for those who are looking for attorneys at the lower end of the price spectrum.  If you realistically know that you are looking for options at the lower end of the price spectrum, it may be a good idea to contact attorneys that have internet advertisements, as an attorney who is willing to pay to provide a free consultation is generally in need of business and might offer lower fees.

• Does your office accept Payment Plans?

We accept flexible payment plans for many legal matters.  Our office allows for “Buy Now Pay Later” through Affirm.  If you use the “Buy Now Pay Later” option, it is important to remember that qualification for a loan goes through Affirm and our office has no ability to approve eligibility.  Using “Buy Now Pay Later” is similar to using a credit card in that the repayment plan would be between you and Affirm.  In order to learn more about the “Buy Now Pay Later” option, click this option on the payment page of my website:

• Where do you practice?

I handle cases throughout all of Indiana, including the Federal District Courts, the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals, and Lagrange, Lagrange County, Indiana.